Ethical discussion response assistance please. -200 word Nursing Assignment Help

Ethical discussion response assistance please. 

-200 word minimum

– 2 references

Ethical Dilemma

          Early in my nursing career, I encountered an ethical dilemma involving patient consent and capacity. I was working on a skilled nursing unit and was assigned to care for, an elderly patient with dementia who also had occasional moments of lucidity. The patient’s son held her power of attorney for healthcare decisions. When she first arrived on our unit, her son insisted we use physical restraints on her wrists to keep her from getting up out of bed and potentially falling. He was worried about her safety. However, when she experienced moments of lucidity, she would become extremely upset about being tied down. She would plead with me to remove the restraints and let her move about. She clearly expressed a desire not to be confined to the bed.

          I brought up my concerns about the restraints during rounds with her physician and the interprofessional team. I explained that while the patient at times appeared confused and delirious, at other brief moments she seemed clearly competent and expressly stated she did not want to be restrained. I raised an ethical concern about whether we were violating her autonomy and consent by keeping her restrained against her expressed wishes when competent. Her physician pointed out that her son had the legal right to make these care decisions on her behalf given the power of attorney paperwork. He sympathized with my concern but said ultimately it was the family’s choice since the patient was deemed incompetent most of the time.

          I understood his point, but continued to feel conflicted about ignoring the patient’s clearly stated wishes when she was in a lucid mental state. I worried we were prioritizing beneficence and nonmaleficence, in the sense that restraining her protected her from potential harm and falls (Rainer et al., 2018). However, this came at the expense of her autonomy and caused her significant emotional distress when she was aware of the restraints. I brought up alternatives to consider at our next care plan meeting. I suggested we use restraints only as needed for procedures and high fall risk situations, but avoid continuous use. I proposed keeping her bed in the lowest position and using a bed alarm to alert staff if she tried to get up. I also recommended reassessing her mental status at least every 2 hours and asking her again about her restraint preferences when she appeared lucid.

          The team agreed this was a reasonable compromise. We explained the plan to her son, though he remained skeptical. In implementing the plan, I made sure to engage the patient in conversation every time I entered her room to establish her mental status. When she seemed oriented and able to appropriately answer questions, I asked if she remembered the restraints and whether she wanted them on or off at that time. Sometimes she said she did not remember the restraints at all. Other times she immediately asked for them to be removed. I would comply with her requests in those lucid moments, while continuing to keep her bed low and using the alarm for safety. Engaging with her in this way showed respect for her autonomy.

          This experience taught me important ethical lessons. I learned the importance of continuously re-evaluating consent and capacity with patients who have fluctuating or unclear decisional capacity. Even if they have been deemed legally incompetent, they may have windows of lucidity where their voice should be honored (Askren & Leslie, 2019). As nurses, we have a duty to advocate for our patients’ rights and preferences when we can discern them. I also learned the value of bringing ethical concerns to an interprofessional team. Other disciplines like social work or medicine may have insight and help find solutions, like the compromise we reached. In complex situations like this particular one with competing principles, collaboration is key.

          Finally, this dilemma reinforced how crucial it is that we repeatedly assess patient response and adjust care to balance beneficence/nonmaleficence with autonomy. There are rarely perfect solutions, but we can aim to honor the patient’s voice as much as possible when competent, while protecting their safety when not. This experience had a profound impact on me early in my career and shaped my approach to ethical patient care.

Share This Post

Email
WhatsApp
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Pinterest
Reddit

Order a Similar Paper and get 15% Discount on your First Order

Related Questions

Aubre R. presents as a new patient to your practice having Nursing Assignment Help

Aubre R. presents as a new patient to your practice having recently relocated from rural Tennessee. She is 68 years old and complains of irritable bowel syndrome (IBS) with abdominal cramping and frequent diarrhea with occasional constipation. She has a history of domestic violence with resultant anxiety requiring inpatient hospitalization

Walden University, LLC. (Producer). (2019b). Alzheimer’s Nursing Assignment Help

To Prepare  Review the interactive media piece for Alzheimer’s Disease.  (76 Year Old Iranian Male) Reflect on the patient’s symptoms and aspects of the disorder presented in the interactive media piece. Consider how you might assess and treat patients presenting with the symptoms of the patient case study you were assigned. You

To Prepare Review the interactive media piece for Nursing Assignment Help

To Prepare  Review the interactive media piece for Alzheimer’s Disease.  (76 Year Old Iranian Male) Reflect on the patient’s symptoms and aspects of the disorder presented in the interactive media piece. Consider how you might assess and treat patients presenting with the symptoms of the patient case study you were assigned. You

Students are required to maintain weekly reflective Nursing Assignment Help

Students are required to maintain weekly reflective narratives throughout the course to combine into one course-long reflective journal that integrates leadership and inquiry into current practice as it applies to the Professional Capstone and Practicum course. In your journal, you will reflect on the personal knowledge and skills gained throughout

Please respond to one discussion post. Compare your Nursing Assignment Help

Please respond to one discussion post. Compare your experience with the Active Verbs activity with that of your peer. Was their experience with the activity similar to yours? If they had similar experiences with the questions, discuss why you think you had similar outcomes. If they had different experiences with

The inquiry seeks assistance from nutrition specialists or Nursing Assignment Help

The inquiry seeks assistance from nutrition specialists or majors to formulate a nutrition plan assignment for a 65-year-old patient grappling with Gastroesophageal Reflux Disease (GERD). GERD is a chronic condition characterized by the backflow of stomach acid into the esophagus, leading to symptoms like heartburn and discomfort. Crafting an effective

1. Read: Discussion Background This week you are learning Nursing Assignment Help

1. Read: Discussion Background  This week you are learning about codes for services and procedures assigned from the Medicine Section. As you work on assigning codes for services performed from the Medicine Section, reflect on the purpose and meaning of the guidelines found throughout this section.  2. Initial Post: Create a new

Question: Discuss the types of influences categorized in the Nursing Assignment Help

Question: Discuss the types of influences categorized in the macro level in the patient-centered decision-making process?Discussion Requirements: Discuss the types of influences categorized in the macro level in the patient-centered decision-making process? You must make a minimum of four substantive contributions on two separate days of the learning week to the discussion topic. Post your

Describe the defining characteristics of evidence-based Nursing Assignment Help

Describe the defining characteristics of evidence-based practice (EBP) and explain the link between evidence-based practice, evaluation research, epidemiology, and health services research. Identify some of the pitfalls and potential problems of recent EBP research.In addition, identify an evidence-based practice that will be the focus for the week 8 final paper.